In short, should I say, "Happy Holdiays" or "Merry Christmas?"
First off, for me this is not a matter of political correctness. I have never made decisions based upon whether or not something is PC. I am trying my darndest to follow Jesus and as I look at his life and ministry political correctness doesn't appear to be one of his core values. It was the politicians and religious leaders afterall who joined together to crucify him.
The question I have is what is one trying to accomplish when greeting someone during the holidays? I would contend that in general whether one is wishing another "Happy Holidays" or "Merry Christmas," their main objective is simply to wish some goodwill upon another person. In which case, the greetings seem to be synonymous. Let's say this is the purpose of a holiday greeting then wouldn't "Happy Holidays" be more effective as it can also encompass "Happy New Year" in it as well? "Happy Holidays" is a lot more concise than "Merry Christmas and Happy New Year." I only have so many words I can get out in a day.
For those who subscribe to "Jesus is the reason for the season" meaning of Christmas, "Merry Christmas" is far more than just an off-the-cuff holiday greeting of goodwill and best regards.
Christmas is about God becoming flesh and dwelling among us.
Christmas is about a messiah coming to save his people.
Christmas is about a king being born not in the splendor and glory of a palace, but in the humility and simplicity of a manger.
Christmas is about the poor and oppressed receiving hope, dignity, and rescue.
Christmas is about a God who saw his children in their brokenness and chose to do something drastic about it.
So here is a thought...if Christmas truly is about Jesus, and you want to fight to keep him the meaning of Christmas, then why not just share Jesus with others? Why not look for opportunities to share your faith with others? Why not invite someone to your Christmas Eve service? Why not look for opportunities to serve the poor in your community or reach out to the single mothers? If Christmas is really about Jesus what would it would it really look like to wish the stranger a "Merry Christmas?"
Christmas is bigger than a greeting. It is an event. It is an action. If we're just greeting someone this season then "Happy Holidays" or "Merry Christmas" makes little difference. However, if we're truly wishing (wishing probably isn't the best word...maybe blessing) someone a "Merry Christmas" then it makes all the difference in the world. It did 2000 years ago, and it continues all the same today.
MERRY CHRISTMAS!

