I realize the answer to that question may be the same as the first. Christians have been eating their own for quite a while now, but its been bothering me more than usual lately. This past week there was a video that went viral on social media outlets. Perhaps you've seen it. Its a spoken word poem making the claim that Jesus hates religion. If you haven't seen it I urge you to check it out here and please formulate your own response before reading the rest of my post.
There is a lot about this video that I like. I'm also a big fan of spoken word and am jealous of anyone who is good at it. The point being made is not anything new. Being a Christian isn't about keeping to a set of oppressive rules, its about a loving relationship with Jesus. I wholeheartedly agree! What bothers me about this poem, and a lot else that I see and hear, is that it pits Jesus against religion and against the institutional church. It seems there are many Christians out there who share these sentiments and I think this is dangerous
Here's why. Here's what bothers me about all of this:
1. I don't think that Jesus hates religion. I don't think that religion has started a single war in history. I don't think that the church is one big hypocritical institution. I don't think that Jesus hates the institutional church. What I do think is that religion is subscribed to by people, and the church is comprised of people and people are sinful and sinful people do terrible things (like start wars, oppress the poor, and judge and condemn others), sometimes in the name of religion and the church. Jesus does not hate religion, nor did he come to abolish it. The most religious people of his day were Jews and the strictest of Jews (Scribes and Pharisees) held on to the Jewish Torah (Law) with white knuckles and yet here is what Jesus said about such religion:
Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. Matthew 5.17.
In his short letter James writes this about "religion:" Religion that God our Father accepts as pure and faultless is this: to look after the orphans and widows in their distress and to keep oneself from being polluted by the world. James 1.27.
Jesus didn't come to abolish religion. He came to abolish sin and the power that it has over us. That is what happened on the cross and through his resurrection, and because of what he did for us we can actually experience and practice "pure and faultless" religion, the kind that feeds to poor and cares for widows. When those who claim to be "religious" or "Christian" fail to demonstrate the love of Christ, that doesn't mean there's something wrong with religion or the church...it means there's something wrong with them and unfortunately they give religion and church a bad name. The truth however, is that great good has occurred throughout the centuries in the name of religion and the church. Even today the majority of homeless shelters, havens for battered women, adoption agencies, global feeding organizations, disaster relief and abolition of slavery efforts have the fingerprints of the "church" all over it. Religion is supported by people. The church is made up of people. People are messed up sinners and therefore religion and church can smack of the same. But Jesus loves the church and gave himself up for her and he calls his followers not to abandon religion, but to practice true religion. This brings me to the second thing that bothers me...
2. I think we're operating with a truncated gospel. I have often heard, and said myself, something along the lines of, "we're all just a bunch of messed up sinners loved by God." This is entirely true and I am thankful that in recent decades it seems like the church has been more accepting and has offered more grace, inviting people to come as they are, broken and sinful. I've heard more an more the message that the church is a hospital for the sick, and not a country club for the saints. I am thankful for this posture but I also think it can become dangerous. We are messed up sinners and Jesus does invite us to come as we are. He does love us just the way we are BUT he also wants to renew and restore us. We may be a mess but Jesus cleans things up. We may be broken but Jesus does fix things. He does offer us grace for our sin, but also to be agents of healing and restoration in our broken world. The church is a hospital for the sick, but hospitals also exist to help people get well.
I think that many of us are walking around with a truncated gospel. For many the gospel is understood as: "I am a sinner saved by grace through the cross of Jesus Christ." But that's only half the gospel. We were created in the image of God but have been separated from him through our sin. Jesus saved us from our sin by dying on the cross as an atonement for our sin, and through his resurrection we are being renewed and restored and re-conformed to his image and are invited to join him in rescuing and redeeming the world. To put it more simply the gospel is: Creation, Fall, Rescue, Restoration. But for many it has been reduced to simply Fall and Rescue. We need to tell the rest of the story. We are messed up, but we weren't created that way and we're not supposed to stay that way. One of my favorite theologians NT Wright puts it best when he says, "we are saved and now we have a job to do." What bothers me is that we have a great story to tell and we're leaving out the best parts. Followers of Jesus need to proclaim the whole gospel for the whole person for the whole world!
And here may be what bothers me most...
3. I think it has become cool for Christians to bash religion and the church. Admittedly, a lot of Christians have been burned by the church and many through their criticism are expressing deep hurt and a desire to hold God's people accountable. How the church responds to such people will impact her reputation, for better or worse. However, I've heard many Christians bash religion and the church who have never been burned by the Church, and if I can be blunt I think they do it because it is fashionable. For example, as many are aware NFL QB Tim Tebow has been a lightening rod for discussion lately. I recently read a blog post of a pastor calling for Tebow to "tone it down" when it comes to his expression of his faith. A pastor asking Tim Tebow to "tone it down" makes no sense, unless its an attempt to appeal to the popular crowd. Tebow may make me uncomfortable at times but I just can't see Jesus telling anyone lifting up his name to tone it down, no matter how uncool. I get it. I went through a phase where I bashed the church because of her faults, hypocrisy and irrelevance, and a few people may have even thought I was cool. But I wasn't. I was perhaps even doing more harm to the advancement of God's Kingdom than good.
So if you are a follower of Jesus and perhaps more specifically a young pastor who hates religion and/or the church I want to sincerely, lovingly and graciously ask you to consider shifting your posture. If its for the purpose of being cool, it's not so just stop. Think about how this looks to those outside of the Christian faith. Think of the many people who see Christianity as absurd because their own can't even seem to agree or play nice. If you've been hurt or burned by the church or in the name of religion that is a different story. I hear you and I am sorry for your experience. Its not what Jesus had in mind when he started this thing. I've been there. I am a pastor and the church has disappointed me more than I care to admit. I've seen many church leaders make decisions that served their own self-interests more than the cause of Christ. I've seen Christians use bad religion to get the upper hand on one another and I've heard people in the church say some things that nearly made me throw up in my mouth. But...
I love the church, because Jesus loves the church.
I am striving to give my life up for the church, because Jesus did.
I don't hate religion, I want to hate the sin that is within me.
I love true religion that cares for the poor and gives grace, dignity and hope to the disenfranchised.
I believe that God loves us messed up sinners, but I also believe he wants to make us whole.
I think the church is deeply flawed, but I also believe that, at her best, she's the hope of the world.
I think our world is profoundly broken and the church hasn't always helped, but that God wants to make all things new and he wants to use the church to do it.
St. Augustine said it best, "The church is a whore but she is my mother."
Let's not hate religion or the church. Let's redeem them both by how we live out all of God's story!
_________________
There are many others who were bothered a bit by the Jesus Hates Religion video. One pastor/author posted his response to the video and soon after received an e-mail from Spoken Word guy. Here is an excerpt from it:
Now that is pretty COOL.I just wanted to say I really appreciate your article man. It hit me hard. I’ll even be honest and say I agree 100%. God has been working with me in the last 6 months on loving Jesus AND loving his church. For the first few years of walking with Jesus (started in ’08) I had a warped/poor paradigm of the church and it didn’t build up, unify, or glorify His wife (the Bride). If I can be brutally honest I didn’t think this video would get much over a couple thousand views maybe, and because of that, my points/theology wasn’t as air-tight as I would’ve liked. If I redid the video tomorrow, I’d keep the overall message, but would articulate, elaborate, and expand on the parts where my words and delivery were chosen poorly… My prayer is my generation would represent Christ faithfully and not swing to the other spectrum….thankful for your words and more importantly thankful for your tone and fatherly like grace on me as my elder. Humbled. Blessed. Thankful for painful growth. Blessings.Grace and Peace,Jeff







